I find myself entirely too predictable... I like B.
I think the reason I lean toward B is that at this point I have no idea what the background behind the character (both characterization and scenery) may be. I make the assumption that it will be a bit darker in order to create mood in the scene.
Another consideration is that I don't see SO as isolated from TWO and as an extension to the 'franchise' Witchy's personality should be different than Mrs Yoop (what great fun she was!). I don't know enough about the Witch to say here but keeping her a crazy witch yet keeping her distinct from Mrs Yoop could be a challenge. I know we are up to it.
Added: For example, if Mrs Yoop is crazy 'outward' perhaps the Witch is crazy 'inward'... plotting... scheming... and such as would be revealed in the increasing tension as the climax of the story approaches.
Another reason I like B is that it would contrast well with the nice flowery dresses of Princess Gloria.
The Witch would seem to be antithesis of her. She appears to be one of the 'have nots' as opposed to Gloria who is ascending to the throne.
What do you think Nancy... am I too far adrift here? I'm just talking through it all for the fun and learning of it.
My wife dresses me. I usually wear what she prefers. (but even I have limits!)
Gah... I just relooked at A again and considering what I just wrote I find I like that a lot too!
I think D would work well if some some of the color was understated just a bit more.
Very nice Nancy!